Did Nikki gain weight?
By: Doc Zoe
November 6, 2008 | (10) Comments
Metabolism of starvation made simple, Survivor Philippines-style.

I have been told that there are queries on how it was possible that Nikki gained weight on the island and how it was that metabolism messed up with their system.

The following is an attempt to explain the metabolism during starvation made ridiculously simple, Survivor Philippines style.

IN THE BEGINNING

To understand this better, let’s continue to have Nikki in mind.

The first few hours are no different from your nightly fast between dinner and breakfast. For her organs to function normally, she needs glucose and she can have this because the liver breaks down carbohydrates into glucose. Circulating amino acids can also be converted into glucose.

After about 12 hours, the battle to maintain a constant supply of blood glucose exhausts nearly all carbohydrates. This is because the amount of carbohydrates stored in our bodies is enough to supply energy for perhaps half a day.

As a result, over the next few days, fat and protein are the primary fuels. To preserve structural proteins, especially muscle mass, Nikki’s body first turns to free amino acids because they are easily metabolized. It uses some to produce ATP (which is the body’s energy currency) and glucose.

THE EARLY WEEKS

As the days progress, Nikki’s body will resort to several ways to conserve enegry. To do this, her body temperature lowers, as well as her pulse rate, her blood pressure and her resting metabolism. Thus, you will expect her to become lethargic to reduce the amount of energy expended in an activity.

Niña agrees. “Not having enough nourishment would naturally cause overall weakness, so we conserve energy by exerting minimal effort – sit, sleep, reflect.”

If Nikki’s body continues to rapidly break down protein, she would survive only less than 3 weeks. So to survive, her body doubles the rate of fat breakdown. This continues with more biochemical reactions (which are too boring to even explain). Bottomline is: the body utilizes its fat stores for energy during this time because of limited carbohydrates available, so as to provide Nikki with the energy she needs.

Thus, by this time, you will see that Nikki was able to participate in challenges and contribute to camp life.

Moreover, if you have an ample amount of starting percentage of body fat, it will prolong your survival. Case in point: Marlon.

But women also have an advantage since women have more body fat than most men.

SEVERAL WEEKS OF FASTING

The average person has about three weeks of fat stores, and the rate of fat depletion is fairly constant. There will come a time that the body will eventually exhaust the final stores of fat and the only remaining source of energy is protein. When this happens, the body again turns to protein to produce fuel or energy.

In severe cases of accelerated protein breakdown, you will see this as people with swollen limbs and bulging stomachs. Think malnourished kids in Africa.

THE FINAL STAGES

Although we haven’t seen this (and we wouldn’t allow it anyway), let’s see what happens if starvation continues.

Because protein is important for maintenance of cellular function, death ordinarily ensues when the protein of the body has been depleted to about ½ of the normal level.

In the final stages, the body will sacrifice muscle tissue and other organ tissues to preserve the brain. Then, when the end is near, the liver and the intestines are also affected. It moderately depletes the heart and kidneys and to a small extent, the nervous system. Some time after this, the angels would be swooping down on ya and bring ya to heaven.

How long can a person survive total starvation? According to The Review of Medical Physiology (by pareng Ganong), the average time was 60 days. Several years ago, some Irish prisoners starved themselves to death — and this was how they knew. Most people survive total starvation for 1 – 3 months.

SO HOW DID NIKKI GAIN WEIGHT?

Now, going back to how it was possible for Nikki to gain weight on the island, the answer is quite simple: she didn’t gain weight! She lost weight! We have initial weights of each individual castaway (taken during their medical exam before leaving the country) and their weights immediately after they have left the game. As we respect Nikki’s privacy, we won’t be posting those values.

I hope that clarifies things.

Till next week!




References that I used that I wasn’t able to footnote properly, so my apologies to my mentors. However, despite my negligence on doing so, I do not wish to forget to mention them as I do not claim to be the authority on this:

Ganong WF. Review of Medical Physiology. 20th ed. Stamford, CT: Appleton & Lange; 2001.

Guyton AC, Hall JE. Textbook of Medical Physiology. 10th ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 2000.

Spotlight on metabolism.pdf (which I downloaded from I dunno where anymore!)
10 Response(s) to "Did Nikki gain weight?"
Showing 1 to 10 of 10

» adventurer said on November 18, 2008 11:45 AM
survivorfan_7, yes tama ka maganda si Nikki. when i first saw her photo napa-wow ako. may kunting baby fat pero it's nothing, ang figure nya is super kasama ng geat smile niya. ang ayaw ko lang yung parang iyakin siya, na parang nagdrama lang kunwari nalulungkot lagi at gusto na umuwi sa Pinas. Strategy lang yata nya yon noon kasi iniisip nya baka i-vote-out siya o di kaya para di siya masyadong masaktan once na vote-out siya. of course, history na lahat.... ha ha ha
» adventurer said on November 17, 2008 11:26 AM
there was plenty of rice available in the island which was a source of carbohydrates. it takes at least 24 hours for the body to make use of the added carbo load it gets. i think there was not much activity for a significant calorie burn or metabolism in the island and ja1207's comment above that maybe, Nikki didn't actually exert too much effort, could be one reason why she didn't seem to lose weight. i believe, nikki's profile photo wasn't taken later, but was shot in the first couple of days they were in the island.
» survivorfan_7 said on November 14, 2008 04:17 PM
Kahit ano pa man ang issue wether Nikki really gain or lose weight, ang mahalaga ay maganda siya kahit ano saan pang angle. But I believe na she really lose weight. Thanks sa info Doc Zoe...till next time! more power!
» dalena said on November 11, 2008 09:19 PM
it is quite obvious that castaways will really lose weight in the island because of lack of nourishment, sleep, and stuff like that. try ninyo maging castaway, you'll also lose weight.. not gain weight!
» jeangonzaga said on November 10, 2008 06:56 AM
In this reality show we could be able to determine though those cast away are just on that game ,but we could realize. There still some people who still can strike their good personality and principles and that is Kiko,Veronica & Zita.Goodluck to you guys!
» doc_zoe said on November 9, 2008 06:38 PM
thanks, shadownmuning!
» doc_zoe said on November 9, 2008 06:37 PM
hello ppwalls! thanks for your comment. siguro ganun nga - ang comparison was during and after the game. pero kung pagpipilitan pa rin na it was during the game - nikki and i talked about it. in our opinion, we think it was because there wasn't much exposure sa kanya. tapos mas marami syang close ups, we think, kaya nung nakita nyo yung legs nya or kung anumang parte ng katawan at di kayo sanay pa sa katawan nya, you would think na tumaba nga sya. as for kung mas maraming calories burned by thinking than by physical exertion - i think you know very well the evidence based answer to that. ;-)
» ppwalls said on November 7, 2008 07:02 AM
Maybe they compared Nikki's look during the game and now that she's at rest.Hindi ba mas mag burn ka nang calories kung gamit yong mental strength kay sa physical strength? Although she was homesick pero cool cya almost all the time parang walang paki kaya she was able to sleep well.Positive ang aura nya. Smile ng smile pa rin despite the hardship, and that is her strength.
» shadownmuning said on November 6, 2008 09:06 PM
galing ni doc! informative, witty and funny...keep it up!
» ja1207 said on November 6, 2008 04:39 PM
ah...cguro maliit lang ang nabawas kay nikki dahil she does not exert much effort na mapupunta sa paggamit ng mga protein, etc. nya sa katawan...she just slept her way to elimination...

Showing 1 to 10 of 10

You must login to All Access to post comment.
recent staff post
» Answering your questions (Part 2)
By:Doc Zoe on 12/05/08
» The most versatile Survivor gear
By:Doc Zoe on 11/14/08
» Answering your questions
By:Doc Zoe on 10/29/08
» "Ano ka ba, John?"
By:Doc Zoe on 10/20/08
blogs
The Cast - offs: "What might have been"
Finally, it’s the merge. The two...
promo
Answer the trivia question for the day and stand a chance to win P50,000 in the grand draw! Click here to learn how...
recent comments
» mamaya nah poh an last nah episode ng 1st...
By: jhoobet on 12/12/08
» JURY=LOSERS
By: gwapogi007 on 12/12/08
» scripted ba yung kagabi?... bakit galit silang...
By: drawdemhau on 12/12/08
» ...dapat ke KAye sunugin ng buhay e....
By: giecon on 12/12/08